[Buellen]

Greetings


I was just doing this quest last week and had same expierence. Turn in one set of quest item no xp nothing. Turn in second set of items get xp message and faction adjustment.

From Wiki

'It is important to note that when turning in the bat fur, rat whiskers, and fire beetle eye that the items are listed in that order during turn in. One of each with the bat fur first, and the fire beetle eye last. Any other order will result in a loss of your turn in items and no reward. "

Faction "Indifferent" or better is required"

I know my problem quest was figured out by add two of bat or whiskers I cant rem which and ill post soon I log in game and check it out.




Hope that helps.