[Brut]

Blaming BDA or Taken for the rotation falling apart is pretty naive. It's just human nature. That's why the raidscene inevitably degenerates into a contest of whomever is willing to sock the hardest. People want to maximize the amount of pixels they get, have the best chance to get it, feel like they're the most deserving of it, ergo they go just a wee step further to have the best chance of getting them. Other guilds follow suit. Until it comes to a point where everyone's socking spawns points autofires blazing. Happened tons of times before, would happen again.

There's already, what, 10 entities that would be ToV capable in the casual guild list? CSGs and other alliances wouldn't want to keep 150+ manning scarce rotated mobs for long and would split up to smaller guilds. Ergo even more mouths to feed. The waiting list for rotated mobs would stretch to half a year or so. By summer it'd be the evul BDA/Taken of today that'd break the rotation apart again, since they'd get tired of all the small splinter guilds that appear flocking in stretching the list even further.

It just boils down to classic vs not classic. There's just too many people on this server who are ready and willing to raid for it to work out with 7day respawn mobs. Unclassic solutions are the only way to fix a problem that we didn't have in 2001. That's why the raidscene caters to biggest neckbeards too, since it's the simpliest solution, easiest to monitor, and classic. If the staff wants to change it up, great, but I just roll my eyes reading these "A/A horrible poopsocking bad guys pls add rotations and server is saved"-talks, since we should all know better.