If the mobs respawned and weren't engaged quickly, then the camp is considered open, hands down.
Rule lawyering aside, someone can easily be following the camp rules but still be an ass about it, which is itself a spirit of the rules, but not a rule that can be enforced. Often "playing nice" means different things to different people.
As a druid camping A4, I often have to either go get myself a pet (leaving the room) or I will camp out a pet to heal him up. If a new/unknown player is sitting and watching me, I'll usually send a tell asking if they are cool with me camping the pet to break agro and holding the camp. If they say no, then I'll just have to recharm and med/robe-heal the pet up to full before killing the next mob; it's still my camp. However in practice they've said yeah, that's cool. I've even had a shaman log in to see my pet there and then I logged back in. I assumed I'd have to have a fight over the camp, but he volunteered to back down, since he saw that someone was setting up to engage. Other times I'll log in to 22 being up at the same time as another druid, and we race to engage it. Yet other times, someone will stalk me while I engage ready to snipe the mob at low HP if I wipe.
Some people are nice to each other, and some aren't. When some people ask if any clerics are in zone, I'll gladly log over to rez them. Other people I will ignore.
|