You AT&T guys -- I'm moreso curious about your first 10 hops -- because that's all AT&T related stuff.
I'm particularly curious if you are seeing these 3 in your first 10-15 hops:
71.155.29.24 <-- seems fine
70.143.193.158 <-- this is the one I think is the problem .. but could really only confirm if other people see it too, might have to run a few iterations of a staggered tracert like i suggested
12.83.80.233 <-- seems fine
|