This became a wall of text, and I'm late now.
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.] TL;DR: Transgenderism has a heavy influence in our society today, most alarmingly on impressionable young children. The sexes have important and necessary gender roles in a successful society. Transgenderism is a reality-detached mental illness that is antithetical to those gender roles, the family, and acceptance of reality.
I mentioned PBS's Growing Up Trans documentary because the normalization of child abuse in an audio/visual medium will evoke in you a visceral reaction that can't be conveyed here.
Trannies aren't ninjas (don't google "tranny ninjas". just did). Do you interact with any trannies on a regular basis? I've worked at progressive, socially-egalitarian software development corporations. 5-10% of my coworkers are gay, and 1-2% are trannies. A wig, lipstick, and practiced mannerisms might trick you at a distance or even in a still picture, but if you sit down with, converse with, or interact with a tranny, warning signals will go off in your brain. They aren't fooling everyone. Don't underestimate humans' pattern recognition capability.
(The question still isn't clear. I don't know if you're proposing a hypothetical scenario or talking about today's society. Also, the question seems fall to the common libertarian trap that individuals don't affect society.)
Assuming you're describing a hypothetical scenario where any trannies keep their mental illness and deviance entirely private, then the entire community is unaware of them. In that case, it may not be a significant issue. The society either isn't plagued by the mental illness or it is properly stigmatized as a mental illness and those suffering from it keep it sufficiently private. But it also depends on the nature of the state. If we live in the fictional ancapistan with no state, and you want to privately put on a dress, hack off your dick, and have sex with guys in your basement away from my family, okay, fine. The libertarian would say that's kosher. However, if we're talking about reality where we have a state, then I and other productive members of society have to pay taxes for your hormones, dick chopping, and/or suicide prevention/cleanup, and that's a burden on society.
This is the same as question 1. Clarify if I'm misunderstanding your questions.
There are dick chopping ads everywhere, though they aren't that overt. You haven't seen the effects of tranny lobbyist in academia,
elementary schools,
media, or
policies? Haven't seen professional
psychologists (and their children),
journalists, and even
feminists attacked by tranny lobbyists for publishing information counter to the tranny narrative? Or heard about 14-year-old transgender youtube celebrity Jazz Jennings taking hormone blockers to delay male puberty who appears on Oprah, has her own reality TV series, and is on acne commercials? Or
8-
year-
old transgendered children, some admittedly influenced by Jazz Jennings? The transgender community has a strong influence on children in media.
It's one thing to have an illness and seek help. It's another thing entirely to normalize illness to the point that it becomes a "community", one that pushes their agenda in the media and influences otherwise normal, impressionable children to believe they are born in the wrong body, develop dysphoria, and undergo irreversible surgery/hormones ruining their lives. The rhetoric and "medicine" they push onto children now are sickening.
Children become
more distressed and gender dysphoric when they see therapists and authority figures who impress upon them that they belong to the opposite sex. Despite research showing 75% of children with transgender feelings spontaneously lose those feelings as they grow up, impressionable children are encouraged toward this and put on hormones to delay puberty until they can get a sex change. That's depraved child abuse (I refer you again to the Growing Up Trans documentary)
Why do you think being a degenerate force to society is not sufficient? That's exactly the problem. It harms gender roles and the integrity of the family, and therefore the future of a people.
A large part of sexual orientation is environment. It's not entirely genetic. The gay lobby pushes the "it's not a choice" narrative for their agenda. You can find research disputing it, including twin studies. But in any case, sexual orientation is different than reality-detached transgender mental illnesses. Normalizing mental illness and then indoctrinating developing children into that belief does not make it a choice.
John Hopkins doesn't do the surgery anymore because it is not considered to be the best treatment path. Former psychiatrist in chief
Dr Paul McHugh
These people are mentally ill with some sexual issues, perhaps even deserving sympathy. However, normalizing this mental illness and imposing it on others goes too far. People have norms that have resulted in successful civilizations.
We live in reality. The binary genders are a social constructs and are built upon biological sexes and their roles in society. The transgender agenda denies that reality. A male playing dress up with mutilated genitals that resemble the opposite sex isn't congruent to a woman. It's factually untrue, and people don't owe it to you to accept your reality-detached mental illness and deviance.
Nobody owes it to anyone to affirm their neuroses anymore than we should affirm the belief of mentally ill who identify as disabled (body integrity identity disorder) that have their
doctor pour Drano into their eyes, who believe in
trans-
dragonism, or believe in
trans-ageism. Healthy people come to understand reality, adapt to reality, and even improve it. Sick people mutilate their body to make reality conform to their own delusions.
Sex change is impossible, and for some the grim reality sinks in only after irreversible mutilation, explaining why so many of them commit
suicide even after a surgery. Once they have exhausted all possible means to make their delusion reality, they realize the reality is inescapable, and they end their lives face the oppression of reality.