[Massive Marc]

Originally Posted by h0tr0d (shaere) [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

This is the problem with your break-down. I shall give you the actual break-down, note the differences.

It's late, in the middle of the night, about 8 hours before Ishva spawns.
You head there knowing when he will spawn, since you killed him last.
You check the spawn, someone is camping it, you got there too late.
You make quick conversation with them to make sure they aren't AFK camping.
You find out the camp is taken and being held. So you try and figure out a way to get the spawn for yourself. So you tell them that you are in that room to hunt gnoll whips. And make the argument of, "if you're not clearing mobs here, you can't claim the camp."
You are called on your transparency. You decide to make your pet and set up camp anyway.
They ask you to leave the room, and hunt gnolls elsewhere, and you say no, and plant yourself on the Ishva spawn. You do not pull any gnolls for whips, because that was just a lie in the first place.
You AFK/FD to go to sleep and wake at the spawn, but Hobby has arrived and moved you to the zone in shortly before.

Nice, so you added a bunch of assumptions.