The journey was its own reward, I suppose.
I mean, it wasn't that hard of a quest, so it'd kinda suck if everyone walked away from it with an amazing reward. Someone should get the shaft. I think in the future you should reward the first few people to complete it with something awesome and unique like Guise of the Deceiver/Scimitar of the Mistwalker/Manastone/etc., then all rewards after that should be uncommon/rare with a small chance of one of the uber unique items, and a small chance of one of the common items.
|