[dafier]

You are talking 51 earth pet. And yes it is close to the same but the wiki isn't correct on the HP. 51 Earth has more like 2900ish HP.

So with MS2 you get 3200.

EDIT:

Yes, 2 damage loss and a bit more HP with MS2. So....close to 51 Earth. Also, you get a cool looking pet along with a pet that doesn't take a second to cast a spell and tanks just as good as Earth.