Quote:
Originally Posted by Alarti0001
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
1) Isn't a fact under half of TMO membership joined Forsaken.
TMO is a Class C guild. TMO exists.
Forsaken is a new guild.
What punitive measures was Forsaken or TMO under at that time? None--Fact
Didn't cherry pick punitive measures. Punitive measures are a punishment. TMO was not being punished for anything... therefore nothing punitive to transfer.
Forsaken reformed as a new guild with no kill history. TMO still exists with over half of its original membership.
Why didn't you answer the pertinent questions I asked you about guild splitting examples?(Cherry picking)
Please stop diverting and dodging these questions.
Punitive measures are assigned to all individuals in a guild class restrictions should be assigned to guilds. Are you are saying that if a TMO member apped to Taken and can now not raid class R mobs for 30 days.
Is the majority of Forsaken the majority of TMO? If TMO instead splintered into 3-4 guilds...are all those guilds Class C? Where do you draw the line?
If Forsaken instead merged with Taken... would they be Class R or Class C? If Forsaken merged into A-Team instead of taking a new guild name would they be Class R or Class C?
|
per·ti·nent ˈpərtnənt/ adjective adjective: pertinent relevant or applicable to a particular matter; apposite. "she asked me a lot of very pertinent questions"
No, none of these scenarios seem pertinent.
hare·brained ˈherbrānd/ adjective adjective: hare-brained; adjective: harebrained rash; ill-judged. "a harebrained scheme" synonyms: ill-judged, rash, foolish, foolhardy, reckless, madcap, wild, silly, stupid, ridiculous, absurd, idiotic, asinine, imprudent, impracticable, unworkable, unrealistic, unconsidered, half-baked, ill-thought-out, ill-advised, ill-conceived; More
That seems more appropriate.