I think it makes a lot more sense looking at the DPS of a raid instead of individuals.
From a sheer DPS standpoint, a raid with 30 Kunark rogues, 1 necro, 1 ranger, 1 monk, 1 wizard, 1 mage, 1 paladin, and 1 SK will outdps a Velious geared raid of 6 rogues, 4 necros, 5 rangers, 6 monks, 5 wizards, 5 mages, 3 paladins, and 3 SKs.
From a sheer DPS standpoint, your BiS ranger can upgrade his DPS by rerolling an epic rogue. Much like druids can go beyond 60 by simply leveling a cleric to 39.
It's an interesting argument to make, but I would bet that the raid TMO can field on day 1 is going to have much higher DPS than what any guild was capable of on Day 0 of Shadows of Luclin due to class optimization and more raiders.
|