Yea, if he was that easy for a 120-person zerg then he would have died a ton. LoS+SoS had around that many people if I recalled, and still needed bind rushing (a tactic sadly not available on P99 due to implementing near-Luclin bind rules in Kael on day 1).
That being said, I sincerely doubt that classic guilds had P99's concentration of dps. I do agree that AC seems too low though. No classic parses to base it on, but thats awfully high dps on him.
__________________
First - Monsters & Memories
Argenti | Cobblestone | Animan
|