They both look stupid in my opinion.
Trolls are fat with skinny arms and too-big hamfist hands. They have the stupidest run animation of any race. They also have nasty ass-scratch animations.
Ogres chainmail looks more like a 1980's mesh tank-top than anything. The legs look like shorts and the boots like sandals. get some leather class legs and you look like a hillbilly at the beach. if it's a Bloodstained tunic, your whole chest area gets dyed red and you look sunburnt as well. it's embarrassing.
The 'Huge Tiki looking helm' is the plate graphic for the infamous Luclin update, which we will never see on P99.
This site is very slow loading, but will show you classic graphics for pretty much everything. Fashion-show until your heart's content.
http://web.archive.org/web/200108011...ion_Table.html
I rolled a troll for the regen and because I hate Oggok. it's really not gamebreaking either way.