Great post Weta, the only thing I would like to point out is that SKs have reduced/capped damage tables by a significant amount compared to pure melee, in addition to their reduced skillcaps.
You have to understand, that fully raid buffed, an SK does not scale as well as a warrior/rogue/monk, which is why those classes generally dominate the raiding scene (although Beastagor seems to be good at timing his last hits). Fighting a pure melee with both parties fully raid buffed will disadvantage the SK.
But then, you pros already know that right?
|