Quote:
Originally Posted by -Catherin-
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Going to have to suspend everyone, so what exactly is there to negotiate... Who gets the longest suspension?
Everyone but Taken, Ateam, and... Omni? were sitting directly on the spawn.
Everyone but Ateam inappropriately engages the dragon
Taken kills the Dragon.
This is looking good for Ateam.
|
Stop being willfully ignorant to how this stuff works. Look at Rogean's logs since they have headers. Look at the column towards the right marked "length" that's the amount of time someone had aggro. Being on an encounter list isn't the best thing but getting the fuck out of there is the correct course of action once you realize you don't have FTE. Notice the very short lengths of time for many of the people at the top of the list. Notice the two Taken bards (you and moodie) who have the highest length of time aggroed. Sev needed to reset and he didn't. I'm going to assume (which probably isn't fair) that Taken's call was that the FTE was illegal, therefore the guild that killed it would be awarded loot or some other convoluted scenario so let's drag the mob to TT zoneline and roll the dice.
There no precedence for punishing a guild for being on an encounter log. Omni actively avoided Inny during that class C kill and that was promptly resolved. There however has been multiple instances of precedence when it comes to actively killing a mob knowing you don't have FTE. I'm not angling to punish Taken, I want precedence followed.
BDA is currently being punished for basically the same thing. We engaged a FFA Nagafen that Taken had FTE on at 10%. TMO petitioned that us assisting on the last 10% potentially prevented Taken from wiping thus potentially taking loot out of the mouths of poor starving TMO members. BDA is currently suspended from our next class R rotation Naggy from an FFA encounter. Go ahead and read that again. The GM staff decided that BDA should lose our next class R rotation slot Nagafen (which is a player made agreement) that will come weeks from now because we assisted Taken through no previous agreement on 10% of a dragon. Taken knew they didn't have FTE, yet they still dragged the mob to TT and downed it. Where is the consistency?? Why not follow precedence?? It's patently absurd that BDA is under a class R suspension and Taken wouldn't be.
Either rescind BDA's suspension or punish Taken. You can't have it both ways.