The issue with rotations and not camping are pretty simple and go way beyond "so and so was just being a douchebag, it's his fault!!" and I say this without any flaming or anything of that nature.
1) If you don't camp the mobs under the old rule set you lose them to the people that would have.
2) A rotation wouldn't work on this server, at least at the time of what you keep referring to as "The Big Sit." DA, IB, Transcendence, Divinity, Remedy, and probably even guilds like Eminence all would have had legitimate claims for shots at the raid encounters. You can't really set up a rotation and then say "oh but it's only for these 2 guilds, sorry everybody else." When you only have 5 or 6 legitimate raid targets and you have at least 5 if not 6 or more guilds that could kill them given the opportunity nobody is going to willingly accept a whopping 1 target a week.
It was a shitty situation for everybody involved but the rules being what they were, it was an inevitable conclusion as each guild would take one step further into the abyss trying to get the advantage on the other. No one person or guild is completely at fault, sorry to burst your guys' bubble. If you really want to blame somebody, blame the people in charge for not changing the rules sooner.
|