Quote:
Originally Posted by Glenzig
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Derubael did respond and say he thought it was okay. But he did provide the caveat that there are people over his head that may not agree. So its definitely a start. But not a final answer by any means.
|
Many other members of the P99 team (not just Derubael) have already stated in numerous threads that log-reading apps are allowed. Derubael then specifically responded to concerns that somehow this app was different by essentially saying "no, it's not (but Rogean could always overrule me)." That seems pretty clear/final to me.
It's kinda like how every judge in the country essentially says "this is my ruling (but the Supreme Court could always overrule me)". For any given court case your chances of the Supreme Court intervening are virtual none: if the judge says you're going to jail, you're going to jail, and just because you don't like it doesn't mean Ruth Bader Ginsburg is going to come save you.
Same deal here: technically Rogean could overrule anything Derubael ever decides, but the odds are really against it. It certainly doesn't mean we should respond to everything Derubael says with a 50-page thread asking Rogean for a response just because we don't like Derubael's call (especially when his call was essentially just "the existing server policy remains the same").