Loot council makes sense because it gives the best loot to the best players. It is tunnel vision leadership that don't understand the big picture unfortunately. In games like WoW where applicants are readily available it can work but if your guild relies on attendance from casuals at all it won't work. There is no reason for someone that is a casual to log in once in a while to help someone else get gear that plays every day. DKP allows casuals to log in as they please and eventually build towards something.
In short if your guild can survive without casuals a trustworthy loot council is optimal. If you rely on casuals in any way for guild progression you need a simple DKP system.
|