[Jete]

I think the Charm formula is correct at least from a bard stand point.

I can charm yellows / reds for about 20 seconds at most with my mana using lvl 39 charm. As for blues / light blues I use my non mana charm which breaks about.. 60% of the time in the worst case scenario. (exactly like it should =P ) Any nerf to the current Charm would render bard charm even more useless than it used to be - since its not possible to charm kite due to faction not working.

This is at 180 CHA.

Edit- If this was truly classic charm would have no level cap as well. The bard mana using charm was put in the game sometime before Kunark. It was possible to charm raid mobs before then. So if anything, get rid of bard mana using charm, and take the lvl cap off the other one. GG. =P