I like how rogues are boiled down to pressing attack, as if awareness is meaningless. I've seen plenty of rogues cause problems in groups and raids because they don't know wtf is going on.
Let's not forget preparedness as in potions, resists, clickies. Sure the rubber meets the road when you hit Q.. but i think when you try to downplay someone's ability to play because they play a class that primarily uses auto attack.. I just don't know what to say..if you think the game is just hitting q, you should probably download
Progress Quest to see what a game like that really is.