[quido]

I don't know why you people are even talking about people joining existing guilds on alts to get around this rule. This is not what was even suggested and that much should be abundantly clear by now considering how little sense it makes in this discussion. The issue here is people incorporating a guild and filling it with existing guildmates, raiding nearly always with a mix of the guilds, and then reserving the right to be considered two separate entities when it comes to full repops.

I think that if you raid together more than you don't that you should be considered a single entity for the full repops. It's only fair. And it avoids cheesiness.