The Penance - Dialogue for Warrior/Shaman versions not working
 

Because I'm super weird, earlier on my iksar necromancer I felt like doing the other four "The Penance" quests, so I can get their beginner weapons and check out their questlines.

Was going to report here if any of the turn-ins failed, but fortunately Monk, Warrior, Shaman and SK versions all worked and my necromancer is now the proud owner of a cudgel, a pike, a shackle and a khukri. :)

Just wanted to give a heads-up though on the dialogue for Warrior (Crusader Zixo) and Shaman (Hierophant Zand) did not seem to work correctly. I had to get the ragged books from the monks each time. Just a small thing I wanted to bring to attention.

I just tested this, and both of these npcs returned a Ragged Book from the prompt 'yes'. Could use more explanation unless I am missing something.

Yep I just tested it on Live and that does seem to be the appropriate trigger. With the Hierophant I was going by the dialogue and attempting every possible combination of "I have lost my cudgel" I could think of. Which is weird because "I have lost my bracer" seems to work with the monks. I suppose that's just how it was meant to be, hehe. I apologize for wasting your time Nilbog.

The npcs may respond to multiple keywords, with 'yes' being only one of them. If you are testing on live and discover a different prompt or phrase, we can add it.