Abacab |
02-14-2010 05:13 AM |
Gnoll slayer[Final] item number 5417 is now worse than Gnoll slayer [Intermediate] item number 5416...
The 5417 version should have been left alone instead of offering a WORSE reward, you could simply hand in the baby for the same exact sword effectively making camping rare and dangerous spawns in Paw moot point. It's also kind of a kick in the balls to people who would spend hours and days to obtain this weapon only to have it completely nerf sacked to a NO-DROP version of a fine steel longsword. I mean if you're keeping a re-vamped paw with the select NPC's that drop the items for the 5417 version then that version should have remained in it's former state, if the state wants to be nerfed down then just remove the Scribe and One eyed gnoll spawns all together and break the quest at step one.
Even taking the word account of the fools who post on Allah specifically in this thread:
http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?item=233
As early as February 2001 people talked about it being "upgraded" to better stats and the well known summonable pet, people in the bugs forum claimed this was a mid-luclin release item but I do believe that is only for the extra gnoll bane damage the +5 on 5416 and the +10 on 5417. Taken into account that Luclin at the time of these assertions on allah was still months away from release one can only assume that the item WAS magic, was a 15/40 ratio and did have the wolf companion clicky, it's just around the time of 2000-2001 the quest for the most part was unsolved and or broken.
I'd say revert the 5417 back to it's previous state, the quest is still rather difficult to accomplish and it the weapon itself isn't really THAT OP in the first place, dont make this another 12/22 Mistmoore dagger situation.
|