PIE EMERGENCY
 

I just baked a Fruit Pie, and the pie tin was not returned to me! Even Brutillus said he wouldn't eat a pie with tin in it, and he's an OGRE!

--panicked NiNiK, gnomish cleric of mischief

Please do not flood this forum with spam or worthless posts. The GMs are very busy answering petitions from Transcendence.

omg nooooes ninik!! dont bake the tin into the pie!!

bugged recipe
 

I remember quite clearly that even in classic EQ, the pie tin was returned with each combine.

Someone get some additional info. Neither EQTraders or Alla say anything about returning Pie Tins. It makes sense, just need some sort of proof guys.

From EQTraders: http://www.eqtraders.com/recipes/rec...r=080020020000


Berry Pie
This is a Hearty Meal
WT: 0.1 Size: SMALL
Class: ALL
Race: ALL
Components: Berries, Clump of Dough, Pie Tin
In: Spit, Oven, Tanaan Oven, Collapsible Spit
Yield: 2
Also Returns: Pie Tin
On Failure Returns: Pie Tin

The "also returns" and "on failure returns" bit is also there for Bat Wing Pie, Beetle Eye Pie, Halas 10lb Meat Pie, Meat Filled Pie, etc. It must be an oversight that the Fruit Pie doesn't note that. Muffins also return the Muffin Tin, cakes return the Cake Round, each of the cookies that require the cookie cutters return the cookie cutters, etc.


Also on EQTraders, in the pottery section, they note specifically that there are only two exceptions to tools being returned to the baker, "Many baking recipes require special implements, such as pots, skewers, pie tins, etc. With two exceptions (Thurgadin shawl quest baking, and the heavy pie crock for slumberfish pie), bakers should need only one of these items, as they are returned during the baking process. " http://www.eqtraders.com/recipes/pot...r=080090100000

Further evidence can be found in the smithing section, "There are various other tradeskills that require special tools. And you can make money from creating them with smithing, and selling them to those who think that forge work is too hot and sweaty. But alas, they only need one of each tool so your market is not infinite." http://www.eqtraders.com/recipes/rec...r=080100060000

Pie proof provided!

Fixed.

did a find on that page for all the pie tins, muffin tins,cake rounds and fixed combines associated with them.

Gnomish bakers rejoice!

NiNiK stands on her tiptoes and does a dance of joy!


Many thanks.