Which is sexier?
 

Balancing sexiness against min max.. I have one final character I want to make and I want her to be a tank. No ogre or troll. Honestly its either an erudite sk or paladin, high elf paladin, barbarian warrior, dark elf sk.. I am leaning toward the erudite or high elf because I like the battle beastly lady in an armored fancy dress.

I don't care about natures defender as much but.. Ill be only gently twinked (I.e. a nathsar, banded armor, shiny brass shield, wraithbone hammer, sword of skyfire) and wondering whats more likely to be successful on the server (i.e. id never even consider epic for any class as a possibility due to hard core lockdown on all raids) ive got the character envisioned and the desire to tank but not sure how much an sk is gimped vs a paladin and I do know creating either is gimpy in p99 regardless. So whats sexy? :p

Erudite SK or Paladin is going to look amazing in full plate. With Paladin you can eventually get Soul Fire for extra style points, but SKs also have a huge variety of cool looking weapons.

Don't worry about what's in high demand too much, pally vs sk is an age old argument but when it comes down to it both are highly valued in groups and to be frank both are more useful than warriors in group situations due to their versatility. SK and Pally can both solo, but SKs are generally faster at it.

erudite or dark elf for sure

Erudite SK or Pal would both be rare. And they have some amazing armor to chose from.

Sexy is a non min maxer who knows how to play their class irregardless of their race or gear. Sexy, and the best group-mate, hands down.

Dark elf SK is max sexy

I believe human SK is the best.

Human rogue is looking pretty good IMO

Paladin epic is not that difficult to get, to be honest.

The dragon drops are the most worst.

Does Ghoulbane drop off the High Elf Paladin in West (or is it South? The one that isn't connected to Greater Faydark) Felwithe on p99? I mean yeah it would take a group or whatever, maybe more, instead of being an easy solo, but that's still an easier, guaranteed spawn that drops it every time and respawns every 15 minutes instead of the godamn LGuk drop or questing it.