old accounts
 

I believe I have a couple lvl 50 toons from a few years back but I've uninstalled since. How could I go about getting access to those toons back?

I'm glad to hear I'm not the only one that has had these issues. I had a few lvl 30+'s that aren't in my log in screen either. I haven't logged in in well over a year, maybe 2 now.
Pretty frustrated right now.

submit a petition in the petition/exploit forum. i dont recall if this can be recovered, but they will let you know if its possible or not.