Shovel of Ponz
 

While turning in items for mage focus quests in temple of sol ro, i received the Shovel of Ponz prior to turning in gargoyle eye. I turned in the ruby, then the hill giant toes, then the "a shovel" and recieved the Shovel of Ponz, without turning in the gargoyle eye.
-Horimshal, 29 mage on Blue
Screenshot can be provided if needed.

someone had probably already handed him an eye previously