Project 1999 - Guards in Karanas not Assisting Newbs

Project 1999 (/forums/index.php)

- Resolved Issues (/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=14)

- - Guards in Karanas not Assisting Newbs (/forums/showthread.php?t=12468)

Guards in Karanas not Assisting Newbs

The guards in the Karanas (specifically, West Karanas) don't seem to be attacking lions, even when the lions are attacking players. They do, however, take down bandits. Is this some kind of faction issue?

One of the guard towers in West K has evil guards in it. I know the second tower from West to east has guards that will kill anything that moves...except for the werewolf.

North Karana Guard Tower (-1235, 125)
Starring: Guards Bartley & Stanard (Good)

A_Hill_Giant: Yes
A_Lioness: Yes
A_Highland_Lion: Yes
A_Silvermist_Wolf: Yes
A_Griffawn: Yes
A_Griffenne: Yes
A_Griffon: Yes
GrimFeather: Yes
A_Pincer_Beetle: Yes
A_Borer_Beetle: Yes
A_Scythe_Beetle: Yes
A_Skeleton: Yes
A_Ghoul: Yes
A_Raider: Yes
A_Willowisp: No
A_Werewolf: No
Guard_Shilster: No

Southern West Karana Guard Tower (-2950, -2050)
Starring: Guards Donlan & McCluskey (Corrupt)
Froon: Yes
Choon: Yes
A_Fire_Beetle: Yes
A_Giant_Fire_Beetle: Yes
A_Mist_Wolf: Yes
A_Spiderling: Yes
A_Brown_Bear: Yes
A_Werewolf: No
A_Willowisp: No
A_Young_Plains_Lion: No
A_Young_Plains_Lioness: No
A_Lion: YES
Me: Yes :P

Western West Karana Guard Tower (-500, -2425)
Starring: Guards Ason & Justyn (Good)
Froon: Yes
Choon: Yes
A_Fire_Beetle: Yes
A_Giant_Fire_Beetle: Yes
A_Mist_Wolf: Yes
A_Spiderling: Yes
A_Brown_Bear: Yes
A_Werewolf: No
A_Willowisp: No
A_Young_Plains_Lion: No
A_Young_Plains_Lioness: No
A_Lion: YES

Eastern West Karana Guard Tower (-750, -4250)
Starring: Guards Kilson & Pryde (Good)
Froon: Yes
Choon: Yes
A_Fire_Beetle: Yes
A_Giant_Fire_Beetle: Yes
A_Mist_Wolf: Yes
A_Spiderling: Yes
A_Brown_Bear: Yes
A_Werewolf: No
A_Willowisp: No
A_Young_Plains_Lion: No
A_Young_Plains_Lioness: No
A_Lion: YES

Code:

[Sat Jul 17 23:34:58 2010] a highland lion judges you amiably -- You could probably win this fight.

[Wed Jul 21 01:58:38 2010] a silvermist wolf judges you amiably -- You could probably win this fight.

[Wed Jul 21 02:04:15 2010] a lioness judges you amiably -- You could probably win this fight.

[Wed Jul 21 02:30:01 2010] a lion judges you amiably -- You could probably win this fight.

[Wed Jul 21 02:44:14 2010] a mist wolf judges you amiably -- You could probably win this fight.

[Wed Jul 21 02:48:45 2010] a young plains lioness glowers at you dubiously -- You could probably win this fight.

[Wed Jul 21 02:43:03 2010] a young plains lion glowers at you dubiously -- You could probably win this fight.

It looks like this is in fact a faction bug. Good catch.

Guards in both North and West Karana will attack lions, except young plains lions and lionesses. Since I'm a druid, I have the benefit of being able to spot faction differences in animals. The young plains lion(ess) con dubiously to me and are ignored by the guards. All other lions and animals con amiably, and are attacked by the guards. So those two types of lions must not be on the proper faction to be attacked.

You are giving Bartley and Stanard to much credit. I watched a Hill Giant kick both their asses. He was down to 10% but the giant won.

As far as animals go though, do I remember wrong here. If I was fighting something on live, and a wolf came by, it would assist me when playing my ranger? I could have sworn I won a duel like that one day in Q-hills. I was fighting a paladin and a wolf passed by, it started to attack the paladin I was fighting.

Quote:

Originally Posted by RKromwell (Post 101247)

As far as animals go though, do I remember wrong here. If I was fighting something on live, and a wolf came by, it would assist me when playing my ranger? I could have sworn I won a duel like that one day in Q-hills. I was fighting a paladin and a wolf passed by, it started to attack the paladin I was fighting.

Odds are the wolf glared threateningly to the paladin.

I've never seen an NPC/mob assist a player. Either the npc would attack something else or it wouldn't... whether or not a player was engaged never mattered. Anything a guard would attack, for example, they'd attack with no player around.

Should any lions be friendly with druids? I thought the druid/ranger faction didn't cross over to lions. Looked up a couple of them and found responses such as these:

Quote:

I am a ranger of Tunare, and every lion I have ever seen has been hostile, ready to attack. All the other natural critters think I'm pretty nifty though.

Quote:

Being a Druid and formerly a Ranger i can say for certain that all lions are aggro and KOS to both (although i'm not sure about Druid... by the time i got to their lands they were already too green to be that suicidal hehe)

Quote:

Oh yeah, they're kos to druids. my 14th level druid got blindsided by one. i was talking with an npc and couldn't find the thing. Was at half health before i could get out of the camp. they hit for over 30 a pop

proposed changes:

-make the karana guards kill lions
-lion faction kos to druids/rangers

Anyone familiar with this?

I did play a Druid outta Qeynos a long time ago...
I thought that Lions were KoS as well.

Speaking of which, I know it's off topic - but shouldn't Karana Rangers and Druids start off in Surefall and not Qeynos? I tried a Ranger a little bit back and it starts you at the PoD in Qeynos, but you have to travel to Surefall to turn in your note.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Overcast (Post 110471)

Speaking of which, I know it's off topic - but shouldn't Karana Rangers and Druids start off in Surefall and not Qeynos? I tried a Ranger a little bit back and it starts you at the PoD in Qeynos, but you have to travel to Surefall to turn in your note.

You can start up a new thread about it. I'm not sure if SFG was an initial start/bind point.

Quote:

Originally Posted by nilbog (Post 110477)

You can start up a new thread about it. I'm not sure if SFG was an initial start/bind point.

I am 100% positive SFG was the starting point for Karana Dru/Rang

Quote:

Originally Posted by nilbog (Post 110423)

proposed changes:

-make the karana guards kill lions
-lion faction kos to druids/rangers

Anyone familiar with this?

As nice as it's been not being KOS to lions, I have to say that both of the proposed changes need to go in. One caveat is that currently not all lions are on the same faction.

As much as I hate posting a statement without a link to back it up, I've scoured archives and modern versions of ranger and druid guides on Allakhazam, Castersrealm, the Druid's Grove, the Ranger's Glade, EQDruids, you name it. I can't find a single definitive statement to back me up on this.

But bears = amiable, wolves = amiable, lions = threatening.

The evidence is out there, somewhere, I just haven't found it yet. Will give it another go later and edit in a link when I turn it up.