Cheslin's Illusion Cards
 

Reference: http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/quest.html?quest=675

Everything about the quest works fine for me except the very last part, where you hand in "A Sealed Letter" to Chesgard Sydwen (in South Qeynos, at -280, -490). I received no items, although I did receive exp.

Perhaps your inventory was full?

If my inventory were full, wouldn't the item(s) have been placed onto my cursor or fallen to the ground?

Not if the item is NoDrop. Testing this now.

Edit... JFC Cheslin is weaksauce

Confirmed. No item.

Here's the list of possible rewards:
•Backpack
•Cast-Iron Warhammer
•Raw-hide Gorget
•Small Raw-hide Mask

After reading the comments, I see equal numbers of comments about 'i got x". So I would conclude that it's a 25% chance for each item.

Fixed, pending update.