Anyways, are going to get two guildleaders for this or are we going to have the NPCs take care of it for us?

i was just throwing the idea out there, making sure rogean would see it. if it was starting to get discussed here i would make a new thread.

The good vs evil is just a side idea, Rogean never said it is happening. If it did happen yes, it would need to be NPC, not player driven.

The whole point is for players who don't want to be in a pvp guild, or any guild for that matter. I don't think the guild should even get guild chat. Its just a way for loners to participate in the new guildwar pvp system.

People were asking if player guilds would be able to declare war on the NPC evil/good guilds. I think they should be able to, and it wouldn't be something you could accept/decline if you were in the NPC guild. If any guild wanted to declare war on the loners they should be able to. It should work the same as if a player guild declared war on another, except it would be auto accepted.

Is it possible to allow two guilds to ally so they can share guild chat? That would eliminate much of the hassle regarding deguilding or not. Say (My Little Pony) wants to team with (Sons of Anarchy), the players in the guilds could keep their guild tags as is but share the same channel for guild communication.

Or can this be done via a custom channel?

It looks good at a glance, only tweak id suggest is the quote up here, 5 minutes seems a trivial amount of time. A cleric/druid can just hang around and re-apply DS basically just a minute after the other has ended. Id put it more along a 1 hour timer, maybe more, just woke up things are still fuzzy. Its probably safe to assume that someone willingly participating in pvp guildwar wont be annoyed at getting gimped for pve for more than 5 minutes.

I'm sure it was mentioned before but instead of Light and Dark the guilds should just be rivals so there is no imbalance in what you wanna join with.

My friend is an ogre shaman I am a halfling rogue if we wanna pvp together we should be able too.

My suggestion two Erudite NPCS one for the Bloods and One for the Crypts. Hail them and they flag you as one or the other. Hail the other one and switch if wanted or opt out all together.

keep a guild leaderboard, and and give out a rotating title to whoever is top ranked each month. could be individual titles also, but not given to alot of people.