'God has a special providence for fools, drunkards, and the United States of America.'
edit:
Deepseek thought for 39 seconds
Quote:
Okay, so I came across this quote: "God has a special providence for fools, drunkards, and the United States of America." I need to figure out what it means. Let me start by breaking it down.
First, the quote mentions three groups: fools, drunkards, and the USA. The phrase "special providence" is key here. I know that "providence" often refers to divine guidance or care, like God looking after things. So, the quote seems to suggest that God takes extra care of these three groups.
Why would fools and drunkards be grouped with the USA? Maybe it's a way of saying that despite making mistakes or bad decisions (like fools or drunkards might), the United States still manages to thrive or succeed, as if by divine intervention. It could be a commentary on how the US has survived challenges or crises despite flaws or reckless behavior.
I recall that this quote is often attributed to Otto von Bismarck, the German chancellor. He was around in the 19th century, so maybe he was observing the US's growth and resilience. The US had gone through things like the Civil War and was expanding rapidly. Bismarck might have been remarking on how the US seemed to overcome obstacles that would have crippled other nations, almost as if luck or divine favor was involved.
The phrase "special providence" might also be a play on the idea of "Manifest Destiny," the 19th-century belief that the US was destined to expand across the continent, which was often seen as divinely ordained. So combining that idea with the notion that even those who are foolish or impaired (fools and drunkards) receive God's care, the quote could be both a compliment and a backhanded one. It praises the US's resilience but maybe implies that its success isn't entirely due to wise policies or actions, but more to luck or divine help.
Another angle: in religious contexts, there's a concept that God looks out for the vulnerable or those who can't help themselves. Fools and drunkards might be seen as needing extra care. By putting the US in that category, it might be suggesting that the country, despite its power, still requires (or receives) divine protection, perhaps because of its recklessness or the challenges it faces.
But I need to be careful not to overinterpret. The quote is a wry observation, possibly with a mix of admiration and criticism. It's saying that even though the US (like fools and drunkards) might not always act wisely, it somehow manages to come out okay, implying that there's some higher power watching over it.
I should check if there are any historical contexts where Bismarck would have said this. Bismarck was known for his realpolitik and sharp commentary. If he did say this, it might have been during a time when the US was emerging as a significant but still young nation, facing internal conflicts but managing to survive and grow. So his statement could reflect a European perspective on American exceptionalism, with a bit of skepticism about how the US managed its affairs.
In summary, the quote suggests that the United States, despite its flaws or reckless behavior, is under divine protection, allowing it to succeed where others might fail. It's a mix of acknowledging the country's resilience while perhaps subtly critiquing its actions or policies as being foolish or irresponsible, yet still blessed with good fortune.
|
and the response
Quote:
The quote, "God has a special providence for fools, drunkards, and the United States of America," often attributed to Otto von Bismarck, carries layered meaning through its juxtaposition of divine care with human folly. Here's a structured breakdown:
Divine Providence: The term "special providence" refers to the belief that God actively intervenes to guide or protect certain entities. By linking this concept to fools and drunkards—archetypes of poor judgment—the quote humorously suggests that even those who act recklessly receive divine oversight.
American Exceptionalism: Including the U.S. in this trio implies a wry observation of the nation’s historical resilience and success despite perceived missteps. The U.S., through crises like the Civil War or rapid expansion, seemed to thrive as if by a higher power’s favor, akin to the "Manifest Destiny" ideology that framed territorial expansion as divinely ordained.
Bismarck’s Perspective: As a European statesman, Bismarck might have viewed the young, turbulent U.S. with a mix of admiration and skepticism. The quote subtly critiques American policies as impulsive or naive, yet acknowledges the nation’s uncanny ability to overcome challenges, possibly through luck or providence rather than wisdom.
Dual Interpretation: The statement is both a compliment and a critique. It praises the U.S.’s enduring success but hints that this success isn’t solely due to shrewd governance—it may stem from an almost childlike reliance on fortune or divine grace, much like the undeserved protection granted to fools and drunkards.
In essence, the quote encapsulates a tension between admiration for American resilience and a cynical view of its decision-making, framed within the idea of supernatural favoritism.
|
didn't read any of it. gn. |
