M'kay. At the time, I didn't know that Tainted and Ruined were different things. I saw *****ed Battleworn Morn- and I was like "Oh yeah, that." So when Cen mentioned that morning star and said the Scimitar wasn't in, it looked right to me.

I'm glad we got it all cleared up.

As far as ive seen ive only encountered the Tainted Star and Bastard sword in Kithkor since hate. I would be amazed if the decaying healer ever dropped it for someone. Ive killed countless decaying healers in the past weeks. I strongly suspect if someone had the ruined version that they got it from something else more obscure that wasn't part of my constant forest genocide.

Edit: boy I'm making such a big deal over one crappy item lol

It's the decayed (decaying?) healer. I'm not sure how many we've killed, although the wife likes to track that stuff for some reason. I'll ask when she gets up. I'm gonna guess maybe 1 in 15 to 20 drop it.