Why not just give the manastone to anybody on the list every 12 hours? Let them no life for half a day and guarantee the item as a reward. Actually, let's just do that for any item in the game. Adjust wait times based on item commonality or rarity. I don't want to play the game, I just want to sit in line for rare items.

If you /list and log or leave the zone before getting a manastone, you should automatically lose 10 levels worth of exp and skills, as well as any memorized spells.

It’s not hardcore enough.

Disagreed, they'll just gravitate to the next most desirable 'competed' camp.

Manas tone is an effective sump.

The real fix is to stop making a post every day about the MS list instead of using the already existing threads

Like this one? You're either going to camp it, in which case why do you care, or you're not, in which case why do you care?