No, others. :)

Thanks, appreciate your response without the attitude. Never played a chanter, so yes as a rogue I don't know some of these things... yet. Thanks for the response.

That's really low charisma. If you start a HE with 115 charisma, then add in level 34 charisma buff you're at 145 already. Plus some jewelry and/or opaline earrings and you're 160+ even as a fresh enchanter on a new server.

I leveled up fully naked and solo on red from 1-51. Charming worked just fine. Get your charisma up and charm the lowest blue cons you can find

edit: You will have to do research on green if you want to be able to efficiently play an enchanter as well.

Looks like it could be a few things..
1. Low charisma
2. Mob have natural high MR?
3. Super unlucky?
4. Blue mob but is it 1 level under? 2? 3?

Looking for a guild?

Ok, so you're a new enchanter, I'm sorry for the attitude.

The original post reads like a crap post to me and he even replies to the 1st response calling him a "petty mutt" regarding a fact based statement about common EQ vernacular and I read your post as crap post support group.

The title of this post and his first sentence is ambiguous until he talks about charm. Enchanters can summon pets too, how does the phrase "higher pet drops" apply to summoned pets? There is a serious lack of clarity in the words he uses.

Sorry again, play an enchanter and have fun... die to charm breaks~

If the only reason you want to play an enchanter is for ezpz charm leveling, you’re gonna have a bad time.

A lot of people are going to be very surprised at launch when their intricately-planned leveling strategies go awry.

Level difference makes a huge difference. If you think you can charm something one or two levels below you reliably “because it’s blue” you’re gonna have a real bad time

Yeah, it was mentioned a few times. I think all the points as to why the charms are breaking regularly have been clarified and it's unlikely due to any changes to game code.