I agree with giving it back and telling him to not be a douche...

Warriors Steal what they wanna

if it's not a dragon, you should let it rot on the ground.

Put it back where you found it imo.

IMO, just by doing what you have already done, you have become what you called him. Give it back.

this

and autotune, your avatars keep getting more and more hot... thank you.

Why whether you like the person who dropped something accidentally has anything to do with the question escapes me:
The key here should be whether you like yourself. Because only if you have no respect for yourself, would you be willing to take advantage of someone else's misfortune.

neither of you deserve this item, destroy it imo

lol

Give it back. I have done this myself and had someone run by and pick it up. I asked if they had seen it and thankfully it was returned, (100% reduction bag). I gave him 100pp for doing it because I was glad to have it back.

Because 100pp is clearly as good as 5000pp.

Here's the general rule: if you have much more than them, give stuff away. If they have much more than you (is a Wurmslayer like the awesomest item you've ever gotten?) then you're probably in the trenches when it comes to wealth and the economy and you should fight for every scrap you can get until you have enough to be comfortable.