I think rotation + FFA on repops (bag limit and very specific raid guidelines) would be the proper fit.

Yep.

I think the real question is will the AC camp in OOT be included in the rotation on this new server?

I think a fresh box with no /movelog would be far more enticing to a lot of people.

This, and yes, without a doubt

...and think of the salty EC fat cat tears, I'd pay for those rage posts alone <3

Guess I would throw in $10 a month, then keep my red character active for my insanity fix.

No kidding man, my wallet is ready.

I wouldn't think twice about leaving all my chars and gear behind if it meant a rotation/ffa repop server.

No movelogs. If people care, they will leave their pixels. You've grossly benefitted from the Donals BP and exploits on blue currently no matter who you are. I don't even want to think how many fungi tunics, spells, epics etc people like me and far far more hardcore farmed. Let alone the huge amount of MQ and SEQ use, and boxing in p99's past.

With the current anti hack, no Donals, limited exploits still ongoing it's a chance for a fresh and focused approach. I'd abandon everything just to level on a clean server with guys like derubael and sirken at the helm compared to paymelinda and Uthgaard for instance.

Move logging achieves nothing. Starting fresh gives the server as a whole and it's populace to build it's own mature feel, as the penny hungry twats would still be on blue 99, not blue2k.

I would even embrace an approach in which you forfeit all or some of your p1999 liberties to avoid the neckbeards playing both like blue and red. Such as if you play on project2000, you can't access kunark or velious on p1999 in any way.

There is so much good on p1999 and I would love to be so fortunate as to level up, create a raiding scene, and an unspoken code of ethics amongst us on an untainted server, with all of you who a want the same.

Movelogs are definitely not the answer. It needs to be fresh, and it can't be classic timeline with huge amounts of dodgy design fu.ckups like manastones, or prenerf items in game that were so blatantly broken. It worked great for Morell Thule (kunark) and Vazaelle (velious) on live.