Previously I flagged a guy for PVP and he lost the pvp flag after walking in/out of an arena. Try this as most towns have an arena some where and I imagine the bug is still in the game.

Holy Crap! How did I NEVER know this?!

idk, i remember doing this on classic live and, im not sure there was a priest of order, but I ended up having gms reverse it.

I spent a lot of time in Qeynos pre-Kunark Classic and don't remember the PoO. Which can be taken a couple different ways, all valid.

Yeah I specifically remember a GM making me run around and collect crap to unflag pvp.

Don't remember a priest of order.

I'm pretty sure there was no static Priest of Order NPC, but GM's would occasionally assume this role when people wanted to reverse their Discord flag. At least, this is what I was able to determine when I tried to research the Priest of Order a few months ago, because I also spent a ton of time in Qeynos back then and never saw him there. From what I read, the [GM controlled] Priest of Order would visit players in a few different zones, rather than just Qeynos.

Glad a lot of people are saying this didn't exist, I was really starting to question my EQ knowledge there for a minute. =D