Pie vs. cake

[Goobles]

If you vote, please state why you chose your answer.

To start --

I like pie because it has texture to it, whereas cake just dissolves in your mouth rather than actually chewing it. The crust, chewy, the fillings, chewy. Nom nom nom.

[Bubbles]

Cake wins hands down, although there must be chocolate involved.. preferrably yellow cake w/ chocolate frosting.

[Goobles]

I must say... there are a few cakes that I will enjoy. Such as German Chocolate Cake, and Angel Food cake... however, there are more pies that I would enjoy more than cakes.

[valdi313]

Are you kidding me? How is this even a question.
Pie WINNNSSSSSS hands down.

No contest.

[Jomblin]

Pie all the way. I like cake, but mostly just the icing. Pie has greatness throughout!

[Falisaty]

Pie by far ... In more than one way.... MMMMMM PIE!!!!!!!

[Takon]

Pie has flavor, cake does not

[Yoite]

cake is usually dry and gives you cotton mouth.

I picked pie b/c for ever good cake there are 10 good pies, you can make all kinds of pie out of all kinds of things. Fruit, meat, veggies, cheeese, everything.

[valdi313]

cake is usually dry and gives you cotton mouth.

I picked pie b/c for ever good cake there are 10 good pies, you can make all kinds of pie out of all kinds of things. Fruit, meat, veggies, cheeese, everything.

Meat Pies.....mmmmmhmmmmmm....my favorite :)

[Takshaka]

How could anyway possible choose cake?

You can literally live off of pies and get all of the nutrition that you need. savory pit for breakfast, lunch and dinner and a sweet pie for dessert.

[guineapig]

Cake is often way too sweet.
(Cheesecake would be my exception to the rule though).

[Goobles]

Cake is often way too sweet.
(Cheesecake would be my exception to the rule though).
Agreed.

[blumpster]

Cake. Frosting is ownage.

[Vanech]

My favorite dessert is cheese cake in its many forms.

I voted for pie. Cheese cake isn't cake, it's just a pie in disguise.

also...

pizza = pie

hot pockets = pie

[nutedizzle]

I can't remember a pie I've had that was prepared incorrectly, but I've had several cakes that were just too dry. So, I went with pie.

[Goobles]

Pie is winning!!! WHEE!

[Goobles]

Bump - pie is still in the lead!

[Tryfaen]

pie - crust > cake
cake > pie + crust

[Goobles]

pie - crust > cake
cake > pie + crust

Do you like your PB & J without crust too?

[theory]

i chose cake, boston creame'!

[Nox]

I guess it depends on the day, but I chose cake.

[Rigget]

While I agree that in general their are fewer chances to screw up a pie and that as an aggregate they are better, I cannot deny the power of a really good cake. I'd marry Betty Crocker if she promised me perfect cake every day.

[Tryfaen]

Do you like your PB & J without crust too?

lol no I'm not that bad.

[Segoris]

I'm voting pie, but I'm including the incorrectly named cheese cake as a pie as well. Seriously, wtf were people thinking naming cheese pie as cheese cake. The crust and texture is much more pie like and nothing cake like at all.

[India Pale Ale]

This is silly, I'ma fatass. I'm gonna eat both.

[Tryfaen]

I was going to argue that pies were superior because you can have meat pies but not meat cakes but i decided to google first and discovered that there is infact a meat cake.

[Goobles]

Cheese cake is an abomination since it dons the characteristics of both pie and cake.

And in response to the meat cake, is it delicious?