Item Loot: Thoughts

[Producer]

Anyone for it ? (1) item + Coin ?

[nilbog]

I like it.

Lots of others do not.

1 droppable item, not main hand, off hand, or range.

I think there should be a greater desire for no-drop items, and that droppable items should be commodities.

[Truth]

server needs item loot

[Cwall]

doesn't work imo

naked casters will be much more prevalent and it hinders melee classes even more

i would actually love it otherwise(if something could be done about naked casters)

[Truth]

naked caster = ez kill. also on producer's blood vs crips server items spilled out of bags on death should do that here when item loot is finally put in for 2 weeks before QQ'd away

[Softcore PK]

Item loot gives high end raiding guilds even more of an advantage over the smaller guilds (wearing their best items without risk of losing them). A step in the wrong direction. Now if the server were like FV, with no no drop items....

[Rushmore]

it doesn't work keep the population strong!

[Grento]

I love it but most people can’t hang so it would probably cut pop in half.

In a perfect world I would love full loot with the “no drop” tag completely removed from game.

[Producer]

It seems the NO DROP would be more desirable and the fact I can gear up as much as I want and have no consequence for coming out in the open wearing my "nice" stuff I think it should be at least 1 item, because I mean in like (4-6) more weeks ganking 1-4 gold off someone isn't going to be worth 1-4 gold but removing their FAVORITE piece of gear because they went AFK or got blinded that's your loss & my reward if you ask me. It just seems it should FORCE you to bag your gear and be on your toes not just run around with your full suit of banded and nice rings etc etc ....

/end rant sorry

[Producer]

I love it but most people can’t hang so it would probably cut pop in half.

In a perfect world I would love full loot with the “no drop” tag completely removed from game.

talk about hardcore shhhhhhhit :)

[socialist]

No.

[Slave]

The problem with looting an item is that the game then becomes all about the no-drop items. You're instantly taking away I-don't-even-know-what-percent of the items out of camping contention that are going to be the most valuable.

I am intrigued by SPK's idea about FV itemization. Everything is tradeable... I think that has actually never been done on a pvp server and could easily bring in population. Plus most of us never played on FV, hmmm it has huge potential imo. Twinks would dominate at the levels they chose to stay at... it would change play style a lot over the time it exists.

Of course you could take them down and get a big item! Sounds pretty fun.

[racist]

give us item loot NOW, keep exp death too.

[jjgerman]

item loot doesnt work.

the people that dont sleep or dont have jobs, and get their raid gear thats no drop, have a retarded advantage.

no point to pretend eq pvp is so "hardcore" cuz its not.

just have fun with what it is


stop trying to prove your lifes worth with eq pvp kills............ and pretending that not sleeping, or playing a character in shifts until your completely geared then finally "pvping" is hardcore....... lol I say letting more than 20 people on the server have fun is a good thing.

[oldfish]

I like it.

Lots of others do not.

1 droppable item, not main hand, off hand, or range.

I think there should be a greater desire for no-drop items, and that droppable items should be commodities.

Again i suggest that we make item loot on a voluntary basis.

Something like an NPC that marks your character as one that can loot and be looted. Only players who has been marked by this NPC can either loot or be looted by other marked players.

That way players who want item loss can participate in it, while others who dont, dont have to.

Its been pointed out that this can be exploited, say with 5 players with noloot status and 1 player who does the killing blow, but if explained thoroughly that this could happen i think this might be some sort of make everyone happy solution.

[Truth]

No.

Cogent argument, comrade.

[Taluvill]

I played Darkfall pretty hardcore when it came out, cool game with full pvp/full item loot, but the reason it worked so well was because most gear wasn't worth too much.

The problem with item loot in EQ is that when someone takes your FBSS that you spent a few weeks trying to aquire, your gonna want to quit. I agree with Item loot on this server, except people would grief 10x more

[racist]

let me explain it to you idiots.


OH MY GOD I JUST LOST AN FBSS IM SO MAD IM GONNA QUIT ---


GO PK URSELF A NEW ONE YOU BLUE MASSIVE BLUE DOUCHE BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE BLUE.

thanks.

[lululalana]

Item loot (1 item plus coin) with a FV ruleset would be pretty d0p3

[Samoht]

I am intrigued by SPK's idea about FV itemization. Everything is tradeable...

There was more to FV than that. Items forced you to do things when they were level appropriate. Magic items were not lootable by people too high/too low to gain EXP.

[burkemi5]

No. As a melee class with little to no gear / MR, how am i supposed to acquire anything if any caster can just root and nuke me until i die? anything good i have will be taken. a naked caster could kill me. dumb.

[Zapp Brannigan]

Lots of others do not.


I believe a lot of people are wrong about this and its in fact the other way, most prefer coin+item over just coin FFAPVP loot. I could have brought 10+ people easy from my Darkfall clan/friends if the server was coin+item. It was the first question (and only lol) everybody asked.


/and for those of you that dont know Darkfall is the FFAPVPMMO *full loot/no levels* best & worst MMO game out there run by the worst gaming company ever, and while I'm in the top clan (just in case any PP were reading this), I do not recommend the game.

[Smedy]

producer is a confirmed poser wannabe black person who had videos of him mq'ing it up on live.

don't listen to this guys ideas, they are bad

[Doors]

Doesn't work aka naked wizards/necros/druids can pk melees easily.

[Cwall]

Doesn't work aka naked wizards/necros/druids can pk melees easily.

[Danger]

server pop > item loot, as fun as it would be.

[Truth]

If you have trouble killing a naked wiz on halfway naked monk I feel for you son. Maybe outdoor but he just gonna yonder g8 yall

Especially with the melee pushback and cast times of spellfile on this server, shiiiiiit flying kick to gnome dome

[jrwriter]

I think item loot is ok but it's not about us rogean said no item loot so you'll have to deal with it

[racist]

http://img202.imageshack.us/img202/6314/bluezz.jpg (http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/202/bluezz.jpg/)

[Billbike]

http://www.demotivationalposters.org/image/demotivational-poster/small/1003/beating-a-dead-horse-horse-demotivational-poster-1267844749.png

Really? This again?

Item loot is bad for population. Again.

[Leftoverture]

producer is a confirmed poser wannabe black person who had videos of him mq'ing it up on live.

don't listen to this guys ideas, they are bad

Yeah I was wondering if anyone remembered this. He cheats, but then again so does naes so woop

[Lulz Sect]

i vote etim

[Combobreaker]

1 item, IF NOT EQUIPPED... then atleast something from bags. cmon