Aggro comparison of some bard weaps

[Legidias]

Since there can be a (Pally) Nature's Defender thread in Melee, why not a tanking bard question in here?

Ignoring the white dmg, what has more aggro, Tash (http://wiki.project1999.com/Orb_of_Tishan) or Muscle Lock I (http://wiki.project1999.com/Tserrina%27s_Whip)?

[DMN]

Tash was primo aggro proc in classic, especially on raid/velious mobs. Not sure on p99.

[Wallicker]

Muscle lock, it’s snare + 2 poison counters.

[DMN]

That's probably right actually. Snare affects also had mega aggro Though if you are killing high Hp velious/raid stuff either one of them will probably be hate capped(assuming there is a p99 cap heh) and you'd want the better ratio weapon.

[Snaggles]

It’s kind of a moot point. Bards have all they aggro they can click.

[Legidias]

95% of aggro would be coming from songs, with the other 5% from white dmg / procs. Just curious lol.

Songs already hold aggro in ToV and stuff just fine. Weaps are just icing. I usually have epic / shield out.