Flute of the Sacred Glade 35k

[Kairun]

https://wiki.project1999.com/Flute_of_the_Sacred_Glade
Best Available Wind instrument during velious era
35k PM here and lets meet up

[Kairun]

A

[Kairun]

B

[Kairun]

C

[Kairun]

Price is NOW 30k

[Docx]

Will offer 100 plat, as I’m sure it’s more than the vendor price and performs exactly as well as a vendor wind instrument.

[indiscriminate_hater]

Yeah sorry to shit on this thread but that's some false advertising. The best flute is still Ervaj's (https://wiki.project1999.com/Ervaj%27s_Flute_of_Flight). Wind instrument modifiers don't benefit any songs so you may as well get some HP and CHA from the sky flute.

[Legidias]

Best flute is a bamboo flute cause it costs like 1plat for giving same song bonuses

[Kairun]

Yeah sorry to shit on this thread but that's some false advertising. The best flute is still Ervaj's (https://wiki.project1999.com/Ervaj%27s_Flute_of_Flight). Wind instrument modifiers don't benefit any songs so you may as well get some HP and CHA from the sky flute.

Wrong. It is a shame you wasted that much time getting a bard to 60 and still have no idea how bards work - Specifically -> how instrument modifiers work. You clearly don't know what your songs do and that's really embarrassing.
Sure.. This does nothing for invis obviously. Lets just get that out of the open. Invis isnt the only wind song. Go learn what your songs before you spew nonsense please.
And if you're using an instrument for the trivial stat difference and not the modifier you should try an easier class. Rogues are pretty simply. Give it a try

[Docx]

Wrong. It is a shame you wasted that much time getting a bard to 60 and still have no idea how bards work - Specifically -> how instrument modifiers work. You clearly don't know what your songs do and that's really embarrassing.
Sure.. This does nothing for invis obviously. Lets just get that out of the open. Invis isnt the only wind song. Go learn what your songs before you spew nonsense please.
And if you're using an instrument for the trivial stat difference and not the modifier you should try an easier class. Rogues are pretty simply. Give it a try

LOL if you think you know more about bards, allow me to embarrass you. These are the wind instrument songs, most ( except levi song and party invis + see invis ) can be used with just your voice mod % which is perfectly fine.

Cinda's Charismatic Carillon Increase Faction by 120 (L11) to 610 (L60) mod % doesn't increase faction gain on p99

Tarew's Aquatic Ayre Water Breathing(1) mod % doesn't let you breath under water harder

Shauri's Sonorous Clouding "Invisibility(1)
See Invisible(1)" mod % doesn't let you see invis harder, or invis harder

Melanie's Mellifluous Motion Shadowstep fairly certain mod % helps, but who the fuck would ever and I mean ever use this in a practical sense?

Lyssa's Veracious Concord "See Invisible(1)
Ultravision(1)" mod % doesn't let you see invis harder or see more ultraly

Solon's Song of the Sirens "Charm up to level 37
Decrease Magic Resist by 4 (L27) to 8 (L60)" charm will only last a set duration and can NOT extend past it, therefore making a store bought flute the same. Often ( most times ) you want the charms to break sooner anyway - YES it will ( should? ) lower the RM.... lol who cares?

Crission's Pixie Strike "Mesmerize (2/55)
Decrease Magic Resist by 6 (L28) to 13 (L60)
Level Cap: 45" same with charm, our mesmerize has a set duration that can not extend beyond thus making modifers pointless beyond a store bought flute.

Agilmente's Aria of Eagles Levitate(1) mod % doesn't make you levi higher or faster

Lyssa's Solidarity of Vision Bind Sight(1) mod % doesn't make you bind sight harder

Solon's Bewitching Bravura "Charm up to level 51
Decrease Magic Resist by 5 (L39) to 8 (L60)
Requires: 20 Mana" charm will only last a set duration and can NOT extend past it, therefore making a store bought flute the same. Often ( most times ) you want the charms to break sooner anyway - YES it will ( should? ) lower the RM.... who cares

Song of Twilight "Mesmerize (2/55)
Level Cap: 54" same with charm, our mesmerize has a set duration that can not extend beyond thus making modifers pointless beyond a store bought flute.

Song of Dawn "Decrease Hate by 181 (L53) to 185 (L60)
Daytime only" Ok, so the decrease of hate I'd imagine is impacted.... are you having issues with aggro control as a bard? We need to have a talk if so because I can't pull aggro while trying to proc my sword and do my amazing 20dps.

Song of Highsun "Cancel Magic(9)
Cancel Magic(9)
Stun for 0.0 seconds
NPC: Gate / PC: Shadowstep
Daytime only" mod % will have 0 impact on NPCs so who cares, for pvp? I'd imagine it has the chance of moving players further away and we go back to who cares?

Kazumi's Note of Preservation "Invulnerability
Cooldown: 180 seconds" mod % will not make your invul absorb even more damage as you are already invuln? O ya set durations and shit because we are bards.


So I retract my offer of 100 plat for the flute, I will offer 10 plat for the novelty on my naggy vox bard. Let me know if you need any more edification or clarification on the bard class.

[Slonekb05]

Wouldn’t a better mod help you “land” a mezz better... yes the duration is the same.. but for example the shrooms in seb have a high MR.. wouldn’t a higher mod help with landing on them? Not trying to get in an argument .. it’s a true question.

[Docx]

Wouldn’t a better mod help you “land” a mezz better... yes the duration is the same.. but for example the shrooms in seb have a high MR.. wouldn’t a higher mod help with landing on them? Not trying to get in an argument .. it’s a true question.

Great question, until stated as official for p99 I'm not convinced 100% ether way, or if it's only for specific songs ( which are my thoughts ).

Current offer 10 plat.

[trite]

Wrong. It is a shame you wasted that much time getting a bard to 60 and still have no idea how bards work - Specifically -> how instrument modifiers work. You clearly don't know what your songs do and that's really embarrassing.
Sure.. This does nothing for invis obviously. Lets just get that out of the open. Invis isnt the only wind song. Go learn what your songs before you spew nonsense please.
And if you're using an instrument for the trivial stat difference and not the modifier you should try an easier class. Rogues are pretty simply. Give it a try

So which songs does it affect in which ways and in what situations are those effects useful?

[Kairun]

Wouldn’t a better mod help you “land” a mezz better... yes the duration is the same.. but for example the shrooms in seb have a high MR.. wouldn’t a higher mod help with landing on them? Not trying to get in an argument .. it’s a true question.

One example from personal experience - Locking down with Mez 5-6 shrooms without resists. Certain wind songs, some charms/mez have a MR debuff modifier which does increase depending on the instrument you use.
Great question, until stated as official for p99 I'm not convinced 100% ether way, or if it's only for specific songs ( which are my thoughts ).

Current offer 10 plat.

No one is saying anything about duration. Stop trying so hard to prove you're not a bard who has no idea what hes talking about.
Pointing out the obvious is a waste of time and you should give yourself a break.
No one says you levi higher or invis more.. or whatever the hell you were ranting about.
Stop crying for attention on a WTS post. If you can't afford a bis instrument then maybe you should take that 10 plat and buy yourself a lambent stone for your much needed upgrades.
Straight up bush league bard.

[Wonkie]

i thought we decided last time it improves the MR debuff by 3

[Triiz]

Great question, until stated as official for p99 I'm not convinced 100% ether way, or if it's only for specific songs ( which are my thoughts ).

Current offer 10 plat.

Should be easy to test in a duel I would think. Song of Twiilight should* have a MR mod too even though the wiki doesn't list it.

*Assuming it wasn't added during Luclin, old data says it had -16 MR at 60 until 2004. Someone should test it.

[Docx]

One example from personal experience - Locking down with Mez 5-6 shrooms without resists. Certain wind songs, some charms/mez have a MR debuff modifier which does increase depending on the instrument you use.


No one is saying anything about duration. Stop trying so hard to prove you're not a bard who has no idea what hes talking about.
Pointing out the obvious is a waste of time and you should give yourself a break.
No one says you levi higher or invis more.. or whatever the hell you were ranting about.
Stop crying for attention on a WTS post. If you can't afford a bis instrument then maybe you should take that 10 plat and buy yourself a lambent stone for your much needed upgrades.
Straight up bush league bard.


Yup not too long until im best in slot in every slot and have played as my bard for many years, I must be a total noob man. Who are you again?

You are correct the negative resist magic would be beneficial, which is the most marginal and practically useless portion of the song as a couple points of neg RM will do nothing. King is easily done without a wind instrument or an epic for that matter, and my god I feel sorry for you if that is the pinnacle of what a hard camp / content is for you. So quit trying to rip people off with this craptastic instrument or get called out for it.

[indiscriminate_hater]

OP out of curiosity, if it is BiS and has that much utility, why are you selling it?

[Legidias]

Yeah, the last thread with this, I even did all the math crunching with lvl 60, how much MR debuff does on mez, and how much a """""BIS"""" flute with w.e 2.5 or something mod does vs like a store bought / 10p ~1.8 mod flute. And it comes out to a whopping 3-5 MR more debuff with this. If you get the PoS flute (for free) the difference is like 1 MR debuff.

[Triiz]

Yeah, the last thread with this, I even did all the math crunching with lvl 60, how much MR debuff does on mez, and how much a """""BIS"""" flute with w.e 2.5 or something mod does vs like a store bought / 10p ~1.8 mod flute. And it comes out to a whopping 3-5 MR more debuff with this. If you get the PoS flute (for free) the difference is like 1 MR debuff.

I think it should* be a -5MR difference between Sky flute/Unicorn Horn and this flute and -12 difference between vendor flute and this flute if Song of Twilight has a base of -16MR on P99.

Also Unicorn Horn > Sky Flute because it's like 100pp and doesn't require you ever going to the terrible Plane of Sky and it's the same mod even though it's secondary only. Plus Unicorn Horn is a bad ass light source.