Velium Vapors dialog backwards?

[Droog007]

[Mon Jun 20 19:07:37 2016] You say, 'Hail, Frundle Frenkler'
[Mon Jun 20 19:07:43 2016] You say, 'what velium vapors?'
[Mon Jun 20 19:07:43 2016] Frundle Frenkler says, 'Ahh, you come seeking my family recipe? After all you've done for our people it's the least I can do. First you must fashion a velium vial, then combine the vial with two small pieces of velium in this jar. That's all there is to it. Please keep the recipe a secret.'

She does NOT give you the purifier after this dialog, as she seems to think she is doing.

[Mon Jun 20 19:09:09 2016] You say, 'what velium vial?'
[Mon Jun 20 19:09:09 2016] Frundle Frenkler says, 'I'm no potter mind you, but if I remember correctly it's a small brick of velium, three crystalline silks, and two glass shards. Then you'll have to finish up by firing it in a kiln with a high quality firing sheet.'

She gives you the purifier when you initiate THIS dialog instead. Seems backwards, but maybe wrong because classic?

I said the "wrong" phrase the other night when trying to re-stock my thurg pot, and couldn't figure out WTF was wrong since she was telling me "here's the thing you need!" but I wasn't getting it! Today I just started saying other things to get her to talk and realized that it's screwed up, at least from a logical standpoint.

[Ele]

Classic, not all Velious quests use bracketed keywords.

[Bummey]

Classic, not all Velious quests use bracketed keywords.


That's not what Droog is saying. The NPC should give you the purifier on the trigger phrase "What velium vapors?" but instead she's giving it to you when you say "what velium vial?"

[Ele]

since we need evidence

The major sites use an original walkthrough (http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/quest.html?quest=1240&p=6#m98533509117536) which describes using the input "what velium vial" and then receiving the purifier. This is likely how the quest was adapted for P99.

However, it appears that other sites and comments indicate that "vapors" may be the correct trigger. If someone wants to jump on live and report back when Frundle hands it over, it would provide another data point.



http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/quest.html?quest=1240

Once back in Thurgadin, find Frundle.

You say, 'Hail, Frundle Frenklar'

You say, 'What velium vapors?'

Frundle Frenklar says 'Ahh, you come seeking my family recipe? After all you've done for our people it's the least I can do. First you must fashion a velium vial, then combine the vial with two small pieces of velium in this jar. That's all there is to it. Please keep the recipe a secret.'

You say, 'What velium vial?'

Frundle Frenklar says 'I'm no potter mind you, but if I remember correctly it's a small brick of velium, three crystalline silks, and two glass shards. Then you'll have to finish up by firing it in a kiln with a high quality firing sheet.'

You receive a Velium Purifier.

Small Pieces of Velium and Small Blocks of Velium can be looted on Ry`Gorr Miners in Crystal Caverns or off spiders in Velketor's Labyrinth.

Original 2001 spoiler/walkthrough comment showing "what velium vial" before receiving the purifier.
http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/quest.html?quest=1240&p=6#m98533509117536

so now you have to run back to thurgadin. Frundle can be found in one of the three buildings across from the paladin guild (near the library).



You say, "what velium vapors?"
Frundle Frenkler says "Ahh, you come seeking my family recipe? After all you've done for our people it's the least I can do. First you must fashion a velium vial, then combine the vial with two small pieces of velium in this jar. That's all there is to it. Please keep the recipe a secret."

You say, "what velium vial?"
Frundle Frenkler says "I'm no potter mind you, but if I remember correctly it's a small brick of velium, three crystalline silks, and two glass shards. Then you'll have to finish up by firing it in a kiln with a high quality firing sheet."


she will give you a 4 slot purifier. it is a container, so you will need an open inventory slot.



Comments indicating "vapors" is the trigger:

This 2004 comment says you get it after "what velium vapors" http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/quest.html?quest=1240#m107963604528136

2001 comment
http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/quest.html?quest=1240&p=5#m99746955422040
In Thurgadin the door just past the Holy Harbringer, I forget the name of that building is a woman Frundle, or somehting like that. Say to her "what velium vapors" and she gives you the purifier.
Hope this helps.


Toyko 2001 indicates it is after "what is velium vapor" https://web.archive.org/web/20010602215833/http://www.tokyo2001.com/game/eq/quest/thurgadin/thurg02d.html

2004 safehouse
http://www.thesafehouse.org/forums//showthread.php?t=8237
Dec 05 2004 at 1:41 PMRating: Good
Lord xythex
Sage
4,595 posts
Rogues can obtain it with apprehensive faction by sneaking behind her
and saying "what vial of velium vapors"

2001 monkly business
http://www.monkly-business.net/forums/showthread.php?p=96286
***Vial of Velium Vapors***

Now, go out of the bank, turn right and head towards the church (stay left at the fork). Inside the second merchant building on the left is Frundle Frenkler. Hail her and say "what velium vapors?" She tells you the recipie and gives you:



Velium Purifier

Container

LORE ITEM NO DROP

WT:3

Capacity:4 Item Capacity: MEDIUM

[Sorn]

If someone wants to jump on live and report back when Frundle hands it over, it would provide another data point.

Checked on live, received the purifier upon asking "What velium vapors?"

7532

(text beneath that in my chatbox is the other NPCs chatting with each other as they are wont to do in Thurgadin.)

[nilbog]

If you ask about a velium vial, does she also give you the purifier?

[Sorn]

She didn't give me anything when I asked about the vial. It was only the velium vapors that got me the purifier.

[nilbog]

Fixed, pending update

[Droog007]

Thanks for doing the research and the fix. A minor thing, but cool just the same :)