PDA

View Full Version : DEX , Proc rate and high proc weapons <Long>


Buellen
05-06-2013, 02:22 AM
Hello everyone

*** Thanks to koros post on second page ( lucy raw data shows all proc rate for weapon currently in game) I havve no need to continue data sets. Seems only few select weapons most raid reward have a higher than normal proc rate. ***

more information :

http://www.thesteelwarrior.org/forum/archive/index.php/t-8842.html

Does anyone know if this comment is accurate for hate value of debuff procs??

Qoute: Mykil posted in linked thread "Someone suggested ~300 hate for debuff procs. Would that be any type of debuff or say only AC or resist debuff procs? "



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proc rates are computed on a procs per minute basis. I believe this is the same number for the vast majority of weapons, but some weapons have a higher adjusted procs per minute rate, and some such (with big procs) are adjusted downwards. The game translates the weapons targeted procs per minute and applies it to your weapon. If you are swinging 100 times a minute with your main hand, and the targeted procs per minute is 5, then the game essentially makes this computation:

* 5 procs divided by 100 swings = chance to proc per swing
* 5 / 100 = 0.05 or 1 in twenty chance.

Now if your haste wears off, and you're only swinging 50 times per minute, the game actually will up your chance to proc per swing

* 5 / 50 = 0.10 or 1 in 10 chance to proc per swing

This is confusing to some people but it's definitely true.

-----------------------------------------------------------------

http://www.project1999.org/forums/showpost.php?p=303374&postcount=144

For Main hand weapons:
105 DEX = 1 proc/min
205 DEX = 1.5 proc/min
305 DEX = 2 proc/min

For offhand weapons:
105 DEX = .5 proc/min
205 DEX = .75 proc/min
305 DEX = 1 proc/min

combat rounds go like this:
primary proc chance OR secondary proc
buff proc OR other buff proc OR other buff proc
ToTC proc
swing
another swing if dual wield checks
another swing if triple attack checks

It's a little different here. Since our dex cap is 255, main hand proc rate scales from 0.5PPM @ 0 DEX -> 2.0PPM @ 255 DEX. The stock emu code that we were previously using would only increase the proc rate 0.5PPM across the 0->255 DEX range. It also was attempting to proc once per attack for the offhand, which was weird. Basically, make friends with a shaman
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So reading all this I did some testing as I remember having a hard time getting some weapons to proc playing melee class before.

War Half elf Level 27 Geared Dex 150.

Primary hand Glaive of Marltek < dam 5 dely 24 proc snare at level 15> , and off hand kicsh der Pavz < dam 10 delay 38 +5 dex proc stong poison at level 25>.

Headed to swamp no hope and proceeded to kill 108 Iksar exiles for the next 2.5 levels.

Proces of killing : would engage Iksar exil would fight till Glaive would proc snare that was not resisted, then switch to 2hander for dps. Kept carefull track of procs from both weapons. yes this would mean I would not see full proc through out fights but I need to keep my sanity and get some steady xp. anyhow

Data :

108 Iksar exiles
The glaive proc performed surprisingly well failing to proc only 7 times out of 108 kills .

The Kicsh der Pavz Surprised me since I would only record its proc if it proced before a non resist snare from Glaive.

Kisch PROCS 60 times out of 108 kills.

would kill 3 Ikar exiles within 7 min.

Conclusion : to my view its seem both these weapon have higher than normal proc rates.

Garue 30th Half elf war karana.

Vadd
05-06-2013, 10:14 AM
I remember using a Kicsh in my offhand before I got a second SSoY, my experience with that weapon seems to coincide with your theory..... But maybe I was just lucky! ;)

A1551
05-06-2013, 03:00 PM
Kudos for doing and posting some research!

Buellen
05-06-2013, 07:24 PM
so doing some math

My proc rate at dex 150 is supposed to be 1.16 proc per minute did i get this right?

Garue 30th Half elf war Karana / Buskier 33 Human cleric Rodcet nife 201 skill blacksmith.

Swish
05-06-2013, 07:52 PM
A nice data set!

Are there any modifiers among different classes to think about? ie - would a monk's proc rate be higher than a warrior's with the same weapon?

Buellen
05-06-2013, 08:14 PM
Hey swish

From what i remember classes did not have a modifier to proc rate.

I know folks have done massive parsing with most popular weapons I believe those where from pop era though. I was curious about different weapon that are not used often and hence i made this data set.

I remember one monk in my guild would parse big blocks of hours on the chest in the luclin zone katta castellum i think it was. green con chest in bank that guards would not assist.

Buellen
05-07-2013, 12:00 AM
*** changed post to show full data set now that garue ding 31. *****

so 30 being hell level I decided to try new data set

30 half elf war geared dex 150.

primary : deadwood stave 8 dam 28 delay proc 45 pt life drain at 30.

secondary: kicsh der pavz dam 10 delay 38 +5 dex proc strong poison at 25.

Kill method: pullled iksar exile no change in weapons just pure killing had to zone a few times as mob would wander into the 6 spwn near spot i was kiling.

fight time: 3 to 5 min for 3 mobs spwn. respawn timer 7min ( fight themselves are about 1 min, some where longer if they went swimming but was uncommon to go more than 1min )

data: 103 iksar exiles killed

deadwood stave proc 181 times. Failed to proc on 13 iksar exiles. max proc seen on single iksar exile 5.

Kicsh dar pavz proc 90 times. Failed to proc on 32 Iksar Exiles max proc seen on single Iksar exile 4.

Not sure what to think about the deadwood stave. If Failed to proc on twice as many mobs in comparison to Glaive from earlier data set even with not switching weapons like I did with glaive.

kicsh dar pavz I diffinitly like for of hander and still think it has a high proc rate than normal.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Garue 31th Half elf War Karana / Buskier 33 Human Cleric Rodcet nife.

Buellen
05-08-2013, 12:00 AM
as title say new data set complete.

vrakilith
05-09-2013, 02:54 AM
Thanks for the info Buellen, I found your data set really helpful. It definitely clears up some questions I had in regards to dex. Thanks again for your hard work.

Nirgon
05-09-2013, 10:27 AM
Some weapons proc'd much more than others for sure

Buellen
05-09-2013, 10:46 AM
Hi nirgon

I agree. I was hoping to find data on under 40 procing weapons with higher than average proc rates. I tried doing searches but most it was just comments haunches how people felt when they used the weapons. no actual data. I wanted a controlled set of variable so I could keep track of proc as I killed. I have logs of 90 percent of my kills.

Weapons to be tested so far:

Kcish der Paviz
Glaive of Marltek
Deadwood stave
Whip of stangelation

Garue 31 Half elf warrior Karana / Buskier 33 Human Cleric Rodcet Nife.

Nirgon
05-09-2013, 01:43 PM
I may even go as far to say that items with similar effects had the same proc rate.

Epics may have had some exceptions iirc

Buellen
05-09-2013, 03:58 PM
Here my data set for level 31 and 32.

31 & 31 half elf war geared dex 151.

primary : Whip of strangulation dam 6 delay 24 +15hp proc choke at level 15.

secondary: Glaive of Marltek dam 5 delay 24 proc snare at level 15.

Kill method: pullled iksar exile no change in weapons just pure killing had to zone a few times as mob would wander into the 6 spwn near spot i was kiling.

fight time: 3 to 5 min for 4mobs spwn and 5 mobs spwn every other fight. respawn timer 7min ( fight themselves are about 1 min, some where longer if they went swimming but was uncommon to go more than 1min )

data: 113 iksar exiles killed

Whip of Strangulation proc 206 times. Failed to proc on 7 iksar exiles. max proc seen on single iksar exile 6.

Glaiv of marltek proc 104 times. Failed to proc on 41 Iksar Exiles max proc seen on single Iksar exile 5.

Well all three data set done and i rate proc rate of weapons as such:

1. whip of strangulations

2. Glaive of marltek

3. Kcish dar Paviz

4. Deadwood Stave.

I am inclined to believe that the Deadwood stave is average proc rate weapon and the kcish dar paviz slighty better. Whip and Glaive maybe both equal but i never did test Glaive in main hand through fights.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Garue 33th Half elf War Karana / Buskier 33 Human Cleric Rodcet nife.

Buellen
05-09-2013, 04:09 PM
Hi guys Removed this post as my THEORY WAS PROVEN TO BE NOT TURE. Not sure why in all three data sets I had string of 8 to 10 mobs where I got no proc's in of hand.

Did 50 more mob test encumbered and made no difference to my proc rate of hand.

Garue 34 Half Warrior of Karana // 33 Human Cleric of Rodcet Nife.

Buellen
05-09-2013, 04:15 PM
Thank you vrakilith I am glad it was of help to you

Garue 33 Half Elf Warrior Karana // Buskier 33 Human Cleric Rodcet Nife

Buellen
05-13-2013, 10:03 PM
Small update and change.

need some input or insight from you all. The whip of strangulation does proc quite a bit, BUT once it proc the first time new proc only apply the initial dot dam and do not refresh the dot.

example from my data set 3 proc's on single mob

early in fight whip of strangulation proc's doing 22 Points of damage that is part choke initial cast damage. then every tick 15pts of damage till choke duration runs out.

a few swing later whip of strangulation proc's again doing 22 points of damage but does not renew dot.

toward end of this mob dot from initial proc had ended whip of strangulation proc's again and apply 22 dam and then proceeds to do 2 ticks of dot damage (15 per tick) mob dies.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

So my question to all as per http://www.project1999.org/forums/showthread.php?t=61673 which would generate more hate.

whip proc 2 to 3 times or Glaive of marltek proc snare twice ?

Garue Level 34 Half Elf Warrior // Buskier Level 33 Human Cleric

koros
05-14-2013, 12:10 AM
95% of weapons had a base proc rate. It's included in the raw item data. Use Lucy.allakhazam.com for reference. Very few were ever changed. Nirgon is right in that items with the same proc tended to have the same proc rate. I assume that's a result of copy and pasting. Pre kunark über mob drops are good examples of items with modded proc rates. Staff of undead legions, barb spiriting hammer, etc.

Buellen
05-14-2013, 02:28 AM
=== forehead slap ====

lol thanks koros never thought to refrence lucy just went by comments under weapons in various sight and searches.

ill go do some reseach with that

--------------------------

guess my data set differences are due the Horrible "EQ range" and My perception. from LUcy raw data

all four weapons tested o mod to proc rate = standard proc rate.


Must grind to 35 so i can use my ssoy's in group situations.

Yardcore
06-15-2013, 12:47 AM
Great read, thank you for testing. Myself as well, was wondering about high dex for getting agro.

Num1RecommendedByDentists
06-15-2013, 08:06 PM
tstaff has an insanely high proc rate

r00t
06-16-2013, 06:04 AM
yall are doin it wrong. its raw proc mod 0 is 99.9% likely whats in the p99 db QQ